National Association for the Practice of Anthropology
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
NAPA
  • Discover
    • About
    • Annual Meeting
    • Join/Membership
    • Volunteer
    • NAPA Awards
    • Donate
  • Practice
    • About Practice
    • Ethics
    • Best Practices
    • Interviews
    • Toolkit of a Good Professional Anthropologist
    • 2019 American Anthropology Master’s Career Survey
    • Case Studies
    • Student Achievement Award
    • Related Organizations
  • Mentoring/Career
    • NAPA Mentor Program
    • Mentoring FAQ
    • sNAPAshots
    • Career Development
    • Internship Tips
    • Position Listings
    • Field Schools
    • Fellowships, Volunteering, and Internships
    • Graduate Programs
    • Why Anthropology?
  • Communicate
    • NAPA Listserv
    • NAPA Notes
    • Submit to NAPA
    • Blog/Social Media
    • Contact Us
  • Discover
    • About
    • Annual Meeting
    • Join/Membership
    • Volunteer
    • NAPA Awards
    • Donate
  • Practice
    • About Practice
    • Ethics
    • Best Practices
    • Interviews
    • Toolkit of a Good Professional Anthropologist
    • 2019 American Anthropology Master’s Career Survey
    • Case Studies
    • Student Achievement Award
    • Related Organizations
  • Mentoring/Career
    • NAPA Mentor Program
    • Mentoring FAQ
    • sNAPAshots
    • Career Development
    • Internship Tips
    • Position Listings
    • Field Schools
    • Fellowships, Volunteering, and Internships
    • Graduate Programs
    • Why Anthropology?
  • Communicate
    • NAPA Listserv
    • NAPA Notes
    • Submit to NAPA
    • Blog/Social Media
    • Contact Us
NAPA
  • Discover
    • About
    • Annual Meeting
    • Join/Membership
    • Volunteer
    • NAPA Awards
    • Donate
  • Practice
    • About Practice
    • Ethics
    • Best Practices
    • Interviews
    • Toolkit of a Good Professional Anthropologist
    • 2019 American Anthropology Master’s Career Survey
    • Case Studies
    • Student Achievement Award
    • Related Organizations
  • Mentoring/Career
    • NAPA Mentor Program
    • Mentoring FAQ
    • sNAPAshots
    • Career Development
    • Internship Tips
    • Position Listings
    • Field Schools
    • Fellowships, Volunteering, and Internships
    • Graduate Programs
    • Why Anthropology?
  • Communicate
    • NAPA Listserv
    • NAPA Notes
    • Submit to NAPA
    • Blog/Social Media
    • Contact Us
  • Discover
    • About
    • Annual Meeting
    • Join/Membership
    • Volunteer
    • NAPA Awards
    • Donate
  • Practice
    • About Practice
    • Ethics
    • Best Practices
    • Interviews
    • Toolkit of a Good Professional Anthropologist
    • 2019 American Anthropology Master’s Career Survey
    • Case Studies
    • Student Achievement Award
    • Related Organizations
  • Mentoring/Career
    • NAPA Mentor Program
    • Mentoring FAQ
    • sNAPAshots
    • Career Development
    • Internship Tips
    • Position Listings
    • Field Schools
    • Fellowships, Volunteering, and Internships
    • Graduate Programs
    • Why Anthropology?
  • Communicate
    • NAPA Listserv
    • NAPA Notes
    • Submit to NAPA
    • Blog/Social Media
    • Contact Us
Home » Main Blog » Member Blog » Governing Council Today: Nancy Gillis: The Fine Line Between Building Rapport and Maintaining Neutrality

Governing Council Today: Nancy Gillis: The Fine Line Between Building Rapport and Maintaining Neutrality

napa September 9, 2013 One Comment

As I write this blog post, I am not sure if there is an answer to this conundrum.

I am currently conducting fieldwork for the North Texas Food Bank. They have developed The Hunger Center, a think tank for understanding food insecurity and poverty while developing innovative strategies to combat the root causes of the issues.

My part in this research is to gather the emic perspective of low-income north Texans in relation to their experiences struggling with food insecurity and managing chronic health conditions or a disability. I do this by visiting north Texans in their homes and discussing these topics with them.

Before I begin the interviews, I reiterate the information provided on the consent form by telling the participant the topics we will be discussing and that if they do not feel comfortable answering a question, they are not obligated.

During the interviews, I ask participants to discuss their health and their expenses, among other topics. It is not surprising that for an individual with a chronic disease and a very small income, these can be difficult subjects to discuss. These discussions often include expressions of anger, frustration, and tears. According to the ethnographic method, I must maintain neutrality in order to allow the participant to share their perspective without being biased by my reactions or opinions.  However, I have also just recently met this person and I am asking very personal questions. In order to maintain rapport with this individual I have to make efforts to make him or her feel comfortable.

In these moments, it is very difficult for me not to reach out and grab a hold of their hand or tell them some words of encouragement. But what is the “right” action to exhibit in these situations? There is not one simple answer to this of course. These are the moments when science becomes art and no level of discussion or literature can provide the best course of action. It simply takes practice.

Ultimately, we do not want participants walking away from the interaction feeling distraught and emotionally exhausted (thought this may happen at times). We, as anthropologists, need to remind ourselves that (despite our best efforts) we, too, possess emotions and empathy and that it is O.K. to exhibit these characteristics during fieldwork. And as we continue to work in our communities and reflect on our actions, we will each find our own “right” balance.

 

What are your thoughts? Please share a time when you had difficulty balancing building rapport and maintaining neutrality. What advice do you have to share?

Governing Council Today
« Previous Post
Next Post »

Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

Welcome To NAPA

NAPA promotes human-centered work applied to practical problems by linking a network of professional anthropologists working across employment sectors.  We support all anthropologists in bringing real solutions to communities, organizations, and policymakers, by offering advocacy, information, networks, mentoring, and continuing education.

 

AnthroJobs Of The Week

AnthroJobs of the Week, 22 December 2021

Happy HolidaysReaders, we’re back! We have several interesting positions at North Range Behavioral Health, Tech Goes Home, The University of Oklahoma, and the University of North Texas. Check them out! 

Read More »
Latest Announcements

National Park Service Mellon Humanities Postdoctoral Fellowship Program

2023 Society for Applied Anthropology (SfAA) Meeting: Call for Submissions!

NAPA Notes September Issue

sNAPAshots: Tamrika Khvtisiashvili

Sign-up To Our Newsletter To Stay Up To Date!

Browse NAPA’s Blogs:
  • Announcements
  • Annual Meeting
  • AnthroJobs
  • Best Practices
  • Main Blog
    • AnthroCurrents
    • Case Studies
    • Guest Blog
      • Design by Anthropologists
    • Interviews
      • NAPA Podcast
      • Volunteer of the Year Award Interview
    • Member Blog
  • Newsletter Archive
  • s-NAPA-shots
Tag Cloud
American Anthropological Association (AAA) analytics anthro/studio anthropology anthropology jobs Anthropology News best practices biological anthropology book reviews business anthropology Call for Papers careers expo profile change mangement check community Consulting corporate anthropology design design anthropology design ethnography Design Research digital anthropology digital ethnography ethics ethnography fieldwork forensic anthropology Governing Council Today linguistic anthropology LinkedIn Series Interview marketing medical anthropology NAPA Awards NAPA Career Profiles NAPA Notes Networking organizational anthropology political anthropology quantitative research technology theory TWIAN user research UX Volunteering

Discover

  • About
  • Annual Meeting
  • Join/Membership
  • Volunteer
  • NAPA Awards
  • Donate

Practice

  • About Practice
  • Ethics
  • Best Practices
  • Interviews
  • Case Studies
  • Student Achievement Award
  • Related Organizations

Mentoring/
Career

  • NAPA Mentor Program
  • Mentor FAQ
  • Career Development
  • Internship Tips
  • Position Listings
  • Field Schools
  • Fellowships, Volunteering, and Internships
  • Graduate Programs
  • Why Anthropology?

Communicate

  • NAPA Listserv
  • NAPA Notes
  • Submit To The Annals
  • Blog/Social Media
  • Contact Us
Facebook Twitter Linkedin

Terms And Conditions

  • Privacy Policy
  • Legal Disclaimer

The National Association For The Practice of Anthropology is a section of The American Anthropological Association (AAA) – contact GC

© 2023 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

A COLLABORATIVE ANTHROPOLOGY NETWORK SITE

Scroll to top
Skip to content
Open toolbar Accessibility Tools

Accessibility Tools

  • Increase TextIncrease Text
  • Decrease TextDecrease Text
  • GrayscaleGrayscale
  • High ContrastHigh Contrast
  • Negative ContrastNegative Contrast
  • Light BackgroundLight Background
  • Links UnderlineLinks Underline
  • Readable FontReadable Font
  • Reset Reset